I say, find a brand of lines and rods that you like and stick with them. Once you get in tune with your gear there isn't much need too change things on a regular basis.
I've been fishing with 400-600 grain lines for almost 15 years now and I know exactly which one of my rods to use for each situation. I do agree however that companies have yet to nail down a perfect rating system but I'm not holding my breath waiting for them.
It does take time, patiance and experimentation but once you find what works for you, don't deviate unless neccessary.
The majority of your fishing is below the surface, so why would you want to give up a major portion of the water column? I've always said "if your not catching Mussels, your not catching fish".
And as for the spinning rod referance, to some degree it is true that at some point you are approacing trying to replicate spinning tackle. As far as I'm concerned there is nothing like having success with fly gear no matter what the fishing situation calls for in terms of tackle. I also feel that fighting fish on fly tackle gives you a bit more control and leverage expecially when fighting bigger critters.
With that said, I will also pick up the spinning gear when it's called for. For some of us it's a fine line between making the correct choice to change gear and tactics when neccessary. The smart angler should utilize all methods and techniques to be successful on the water.
That's all,
Out,
E-Z MURF
 |